NHL Power Brokers to Meet

As the weather warms that means the General Managers of the NHL go south to Florida for the meeting of the minds.  Last year the Commissioner laid out a plan to help curb the concussion issue in the NHL with ideas that included: the quiet room, expansion of Rule 48 and increased penalties from Shanahan.

Where has that gotten the sport in relation to concussions; if you look by pure number it would be an actual increase, however I do believe those measures have indeed helped.  But there is more they (GM’s) and league can do, if they want to.  Part of fostering a game/sport is to realize that there needs to be changes, often ones that go against tradition and the good ol’ days.  People, including those that run hockey seem to forget that this game was not invented with today’s player in mind, the speed and skill has far outgrown this pastime, change is inevitable.

What can the NHL do to make the concussion issue better – don’t ask the Deputy Commissioner;

“There’s nothing we can do that doesn’t change the game fundamentally that’s going to eliminate concussions in our game,” deputy commissioner Bill Daly told The Canadian Press earlier this season. “Bottom line is they’re a fact of life in a contact sport — not just ours — and they continue to be a fact of life.

“As long as we understand the nature of these injuries and we’re approaching it responsibly, which I would suggest we are, there’s not a whole lot more we can do about it.”

Daly is just keeping the good ol’ boys happy by saying that, the truth of the matter there are changes that can be made that don’t affect game play ONE BIT;

  • Remove all head contact, accidental or intentional, make it a minor at the least
  • If you can’t ban fighting, limit the number of fights a person/team can have a season – at the same time protect those players that make a living throwing their head in front of fists
  • Expand the playing surface

You see there are changes that can be made, the problem is that it takes effort and money and the above changes impact the game far less than the re-introduction of the redline.  The league and the commissioner need to grow a set and stand up the to the old guard and understand that for the game to survive changes will have to be made.


2 thoughts on “NHL Power Brokers to Meet

  1. Paul Busch March 13, 2012 / 08:32

    The fighitng issue should be a no brainer (sorry) as this is something already against the rules but tolerated by the league. Even if fights only cause 3% or 4% (NHL stated figures) then it an easy percentage to reduce. Just add a game misconduct for any fight and the number will drop immediately. Any regular player will be far less likely to agree to a fight and staged fights by one-dimensional player will disappear, and those enforcers will be replaced on the roster with more skill.

    There is a culture in the league where the perception of NHL execs, coaches and players is fighting somehow polices the game. I believe that the opposite is true, that fighting actually contributes to the violence. On my blog – http://itsnotpartofthegame.blogspot.com/ – I have posted statistics from the past 12 seasons that show when fighitng is reduced, non-fighting PIMs are also reduced. And when teams fight more often, they are assessed more non-fighitng PIM. I think this needs more study but the trend shows that if you control the fighting the game is cleaner.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s