Research That Should Stop You In Your Tracks

OK, that title may be hyperbole, but the new research out of Canada should make you take a step back and realize what our fine researchers are now able to discover.  Considering the context of hockey it shouldn’t be shocking that this was found in Canada (since posting we have been informed that work was done on both sides of the border), but really for a long while now some of the best work on concussions is coming from the North, for whatever reason (no disrespect to the US scientists).

Now that I effectively pissed off a few readers with the last comment, here is what was found by Dr. Paul Echlin and team:

  • concussions alter the white matter of the brain
  • structural damage can now be seen
  • MRI was used
  • this is both males and females
  • brain vascular changes were noted in males only, but resolved at two months
  • comparison with control counterparts showed that concussed individuals had white mater changes at end of season (upon being fully resolved from injury)

From the CTV News article (video at jump); 

“It means we’re finding organic, objective evidence of this trauma,” said Dr. Paul Echlin, a sports medicine physician in Burlington, Ont., who led the studies.

“We know that trauma occurs. We know that in soft tissue you’re going to have these findings of inflammation and neuroplasticity, which means changes in the structure, but we’d never seen it before.”

Now would be a great time to stress there should be NO LEAP to long-term damage being present…  At this time…

“We don’t know what the long-term effects are. I think we’re still at a stage where it’s too early to tell,” said Martha Shenton, director of the psychiatry neuroimaging laboratory at Brigham and Women’s Hospital and co-principal author with Echlin on the studies.

“I think one has to be careful here and not say, ‘Hey, we’re showing permanent damage,”‘ Shenton said from Boston. “We aren’t saying that. We’re saying there’s evidence of changes here and we don’t know whether they’re going to be long term or whether they’re going to resolve and what they’re associated with.

“But it’s at least a little kind of warning … that if someone has a concussion, don’t send them back (to play) right away, give them the proper rest period they need before they get a secondary impact, which can actually be fatal.”

Note that this is in hockey players, a collision sport, that in most cases under 14 it is non-checking.  In girls/women’s hockey checking has not been allowed in most leagues, ever.  Concussions happen in any sport and in life in general, we should take stock in the fact that we are now seeing structural changes; long been theorized but never realized, until now.

It is not the actual injury of concussion that is the problem, it is the mismanagement of the injury that is the true problem in this issue. (trademarked/registered).  This goes to show the importance of my mantra.

4 thoughts on “Research That Should Stop You In Your Tracks

  1. jbloggs February 6, 2014 / 09:25

    So much for hit counts, Heads Up and Sensors. Since we can now view the damage, it is now “real.” We new it was real from validated NP testing years ago, but seeing is believing for most.

    It makes life much easier since the CDC and the NIH will both have to bail on their marketing agreements with the NFL. Collisions sports health risks can’t be hidden and bogus definitions offered by the NFL hacks like Stan Herring, Joe Maroon and Julian Bailes should no longer should have any sway.

    Children should not be exposed to brain damage especially when they young. 14 and under collision sports should be done away with. After Friday Night Tykes it is a slam dunk anyway (the coaches get disciplined for being filmed as this behavior is far too common – see USA of Football).

    Anyone choosing to participate over that age should be warned in hard terms of the potential consequences – brain damage, CTE, vision impairment with the likelihood of such an outcome. It should not have much Impact of High School and non-FBS college ball but pros will need to think long and hard about their career choice.

    If their is no qualified sideline medical care for practice and games can no longer offer collision sports.

  2. John Doherty February 6, 2014 / 10:54

    The work on this study was done on both sides of the border.

    • Dustin Fink February 6, 2014 / 11:04

      will reflect that in the post, thanks…

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s