Is Rugby Staring Down The Barrel

We have highlighted the “slow” response to the concussion issue that rugby has struggled with in the recent past.  Sure the International Rugby Board (IRB) has given monies for research and looked into their policies, traditionally the sports outside of North America have not been as concerned with the issue.  Heck the first article taking the sport to task was the one linked above.

Just like the previous article the Irish Times has once again brought it to the forefront.  After framing the story with the law suit filed by the former NFL players the IT looks at rugby;

Within the last year professional Irish rugby players Bernard Jackman and John Fogarty have both retired from the game due to ongoing issues with concussion, while the International Rugby Board (IRB) last month issued a new “more robust” set of guidelines regarding the recognition and treatment of concussion in players.

Players are not permitted to wear heavily-padded protection, which was being promoted by Australian back Berrick Barnes, who recently took time out of the game because of repeated concussions, but now hopes to play in this summer’s World Cup.

Biomechanics expert Dr Andrew McIntosh completed a study for the IRB and Australian Rules on the effectiveness of headgear in concussion prevention. His report showed the standard headgear approved by the IRB made no difference to concussion rates when compared with players who wore no headgear.

“I was struggling with cognitive tests and had been getting the symptoms for a while so I suppose I was at the high end of things,” Fogarty told The Irish Times last month. “When I got knocked out playing for Leinster against Treviso it didn’t take too much at all. It was a fella’s head that glanced off my face.”

For many years people have had the thought that without helmets sports like rugby did not have the affinity for head injuries, mainly due to players not using the equipment as weapons, and the feeling of safety inside the equipment.  The biggest flaw with that line of thinking is that you DO NOT HAVE TO BE HIT IN THE HEAD to sustain a concussion.

We will be keeping an eye on the international response to concussions as we go forward.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s