NOCSAE; Alan Schwarz Follow Up


As we mentioned going into the Winter Board Meetings of NOCSAE, renowned reporter on head injuries, Alan Schwarz of the New York Times, was in attendance.  Yesterday we posted parts of the press release from Arizona, in this article Schwarz dives deeper, and using his incredible knowledge about this issue went much deeper than a presser;

“We ultimately came to the conclusion that yes, it would be desirable to look and study and try to understand if we can come up with a meaningful youth football helmet standard,” said Cantu, a clinical professor of neurosurgery at Boston University. He added that a lower-force standard (which Nocsae requires for lacrosse helmets) and tests for more complex rotational forces would be pursued, but said, “The science that tells us where we should set it is not available today.”

Cantu was followed by David Halstead, Nocsae’s technical director and top expert on helmet physics, who theorized that football concussions derived from forces too numerous and complex for helmets to protect against them any better than they currently do. He said that testing helmets against rotational forces “will not lead to a reduction” in concussions, adding, “We’ve got a lot of information, but we don’t know what to do next.”

There was a lot of information talked about behind closed-doors, Schwarz had the opportunity to dive into some issues that were being discussed there;

Most of Nocsae’s two-day meeting was closed to the public and the safety commission. One matter discussed in the private sessions was a recent request by Nocsae to helmet manufacturers, asking them to turn over the last 10 years of their in-house testing data for examination. (In one company’s case, those records exceeded 27,000 pages.) Nocsae officials said they did not recall such a request in the past 10 years, as manufacturers have generally been trusted to follow Nocsae’s quality-control rules.

In an interview Friday, Mike Oliver, Nocsae’s executive director, expressed concern that some manufacturers might not have drop-tested as many helmets as they should have to meet the Nocsae standard, although further investigation was necessary. Halstead, Nocsae’s technical director, added that noncompliance would not necessarily mean any safety problems for helmets currently in use.

“Someone could be in violation of the licensing agreement, you might put them on notice — ‘Hey, you haven’t done what you’re supposed to do’ — but that may not be a comment about how the helmets perform at all,” Halstead said.

Once again I would like to thank Schwarz for his continual efforts to maintain some “transparency” during the concussion issue.

3 thoughts on “NOCSAE; Alan Schwarz Follow Up

  1. Sacy Bryant January 26, 2011 / 15:10

    Alan Schwarz is awesome but we need a favor .interview some therapeutic hypothermia neurologists possibly some at the Miami Project to Prevent Paralysis,or NYC Columbia trauma doctors, any of them. We are getting no encouragement to cool brains of players to minimize the secondary injury. To me it seems like a case of no money to be made off ice packs on the neck and head so it can’t really help.A T could spearhead research.In the meantime please ice heads and necks if someone gets an SCI or a concussion.Thanks,SB.

    • Dustin Fink January 26, 2011 / 15:18

      Stacey,
      Yes! Someone thinks what I have been thinking… I even approached a local emergency room to see if there was any reason NOT to (other than hypothermia) deliver cooled sailine in TBI cases… The answer was no, then I asked why they are/would not do it… Something about, blah blah blah…

      I have always iced heads/necks… Great point!!!

      • Sacy Bryant February 2, 2011 / 19:34

        Dustin,thanks.The cooling should be external. Nobody will need an I.V.to institute therapeutic hypothermia for a concussion.Just ice packs to the head and neck. And double helpings on the call for more(any) research on therapeutic hypothermia treatment for concussion.S.B.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s